Before we can even answer if a line should be zoomed or not, questions need to be answered such as what purpose is the line serving?

An image of lots of curvy lines and round planet looking things as if to indicate or imply a solar system
Should these lines zoom? Image by Author and MidJourney

Hi Elise, a great article.

I just wanted to comment regarding 1px border lines—to zoom or not zoom—the question is more nuanced than it may appear. And it relates to visual contrast, i.e. the perceived difference between the line color and its background.

While the WCAG 2 guideline makes statements regarding color contrast, the fact is that human contrast perception is first, or perhaps I should say "strongly", a factor of the spatial quality—i.e. the line thickness or font weight. Not the color per se.

A better way to consider this is that, for a certain weight or thickness, we need to compensate for the loss of contrast sensitivity by increasing the color distance/difference.

(Technically: for a given "spatial frequency" higher than about 8cpd (cycles per degree), contrast sensitivity (CS) drops rapidly, and requires a commensurate increase in the luminance difference to accommodate the CS loss.)

When we increase thickness/size we also increase contrast, at least until we get into the contrast constancy zone.

So, whether or not a line thickness needs to zoom, has much to do with its present visual contrast. And importantly, a line as a divider or border for a form does not have the same contrast requirements as text, to serve most user needs, as our visual cortex and subsequent neurological processing, process different stimuli based on certain aspects of the use-case.

Which is a long way to say we process a line or edge differently than letter-forms, the latter of which are sent to the visual word form area for pre-lexical processing.

Most text, and thin lines, are a part of the achromatic luminance channel in the human vision system-that is, lightness/darkness without regard to color as in hue or saturation.

Different impairments create various challenges, remarkably different for each individual. What is right for one is not necessarily right for another.

So then, before we can even answer if a line should be zoomed or not, questions need to be answered such as what purpose is the line serving?

Thank you for reading

Andrew Somers
W3C Invited Expert
AGWG & WCAG 3
Director of Research @
Inclusive Reading Technologies

A graphic example of how human contrast sensitivity works, with the contrast sensitivity curve and text at various sizes to relate the abstract science to practical reality.
A graphic example of how human contrast sensitivity works, with the contrast sensitivity curve and text at various sizes to relate the abstract science to practical reality. All of the sample text elements are the same color. They appear lighter because they increase in spatial frequency.

Notes Regarding Lines and Zooming was originally published in Tangled Web on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.