Picture it: Columbus, Ohio. The year two thousand. August.

I am, at this point in my life, obsessed with Pearl Jam, and I have just watched Pearl Jam bring down the 20,000-seat Polaris Amphitheater for over two hours.

As we’re packing up to leave, I overhear two dudes in front of me discussing what they’ve just seen. “I guess it was a good show,” one says.

“Yeah, if you liked No Code!” says the other, referring to Pearl Jam’s relatively unloved fourth studio album that featured prominently on the set list.

Screen capture from The Simpsons with two concert attendees. The first asks “Are you being sarcastic, dude?” and the other replies “I don’t even know anymore.”

Obligatory Simpsons .gif aside, I actually would have said the same thing. But, like, sincerely.

I fucking love No Code. It has “Off He Goes.”

Play video

If you fired up that video, saw it was six minutes long, and thought, “six minutes for one song! I could listen to 82 Ramones songs in that time! Or watch at least nine seasons of a well-regarded BBC comedy series!” I feel you, but also I promise those six minutes fly by.

Either way, here’s the lyrics:

Know a man
His face seems pulled and tense
Like he’s riding on a motorbike in the strongest winds
So I approach with tact
Suggest that he should relax
But he’s always moving much too fast
Said he’ll see me on the flip side
Of this trip he’s taken for a ride

He’s been takin’ too much on
Off he goes
With his perfectly unkept clothes
There he goes

He’s yet to come back
But I’ve seen his picture
Doesn’t look the same up on the rack
We go way back
I wonder bout his insides
It’s like his thoughts are too big for his size

He’s been taken…where? I don’t know
Off he goes
With his perfectly unkept hope
There he goes

And now I rub my eyes for he has returned
Seems my preconceptions are what should have been burned
For he still smiles and he’s still strong
Nothing’s changed, but the surrounding bullshit that has grown
And now he’s home and we’re laughing
Like we always did
My same old same old friend

Until a quarter-to-ten
I saw the strain creep in
He seems distracted and I know just what is gonna happen next

Before his first step
He is off again


I have three siblings; two brothers, one sister.

We are all by nature a little competitive, and we all funnel that into a shared pastime — nay, passion — of ceaselessly, loudly speculating about which of us is the “favorite” child, always over the protestations of our mother who loves us all equally she claims. (She has been outvoted on this.)

I’m the oldest, the first-born, the O.G., the one with this neat-o website with my name on it, so all the others think the favorite is me.

Meanwhile, I figure that I can’t possibly be #1. Unlike my brothers and sister, I haven’t given my parents any grandchildren, a state of affairs that knocks me down to at best third-favori — no.

No, no, no that can’t possibly be right.

Second-favorite.


Pearl Jam fandom is uniquely rewarding: it feels like the band is on your side. After all, this is the band that tried and sadly failed to break Ticketmaster in the ’90s, sacrificing untold millions in revenue and nearly tanking their career to keep concert tickets cheap.

This is also the band that started to put out high-quality ✨official✨ recordings of every concert performance so attendees could buy a memento and obsessives didn’t have to gamble on underground bootlegs.

Indeed, if I want to revisit that August 2000 show in Columbus, I can fish out my own copy of the concert recording, or, wildly, pull it up on Spotify, along with any of the other hundreds of concert recordings the band pressed.

Their spirit has an echo these days in Taylor Swift, who also has a bone to pick with Ticketmaster and — I say this with kindness, I swear — an army of obsessive fans.

Her recent ✨official✨ concert movie could be seen uncharitably as a cash-grab on top of what is already an outlandishly lucrative tour, but I see it as a gift to her fans — the fans who couldn’t get a ticket or the fans who couldn’t afford a ticket or the fans who can’t get enough or the fans who just want to see Taylor perform in close-up on a huge theater screen instead of on the other side of an arena.

Good on her.


One way Pearl Jam fandom is not rewarding (and another way Pearl Jam and Taylor Swift echo) is if you need your band to explain the precise meaning of its songs.

(Although, sure, we all know who “Dear John” is about.)

That said, “Off He Goes” is straightforward. There’s no songwriting tricks like it’s-actually-about-impending-fatherhood subtext or it’s-about-drugs-OR-IS-IT mystery. We are not approaching the “true Radiohead experience” of “80 percent confusion, 20 percent feigned understanding” here. It’s possibly the least cryptic song Pearl Jam has ever written.

You’ve got two dudes. Friends. They’re unnamed, so I’ll call them The One Who Stays, and The One Who Goes. Each acts accordingly.

Well, that’s about it, really.

However, the best stories — even when they’re simple — are open to interpretation. A quick reading of one forum discussion about the song’s meaning has folks that hear it as being about:

  • The One Who Goes is Eddie Vedder’s shitty friend
  • The One Who Goes suffers from drug addiction
  • The One Who Goes is only on an acid trip
  • The One Who Goes is Neil Young, someone heard once [citation needed]
  • The One Who Stays is Pearl Jam’s at-the-time drummer Jack Irons who was unhappy while touring but then he left the band so… he’s The One Who Goes now?
  • The One Who Stays and The One Who Goes are simultaneously both Eddie Vedder as he looks at a picture of himself on a magazine cover and doesn’t recognize the man, who is him but also not.

Bit of foreshadowing: that last one — which is bonkers but also I love it — is not right; however, it is also not entirely wrong.


While I know that it’s incredibly reductive to split the world into just two kinds of people, if I had to sort myself I would self-identify as The One Who Stays.

I’m getting a little older, man! I still enjoy traveling, but I don’t find myself dreaming about it all the time. I’m writing this on my new deck. I admire the pre-Gandalf-showing-up Hobbits who just want to smoke a pipe, speculate on their neighbors’ activities, and appreciate potatoes. I enjoy hearing what kinds of birds are in my backyard today. I drive a Volvo, although I’m thinking about getting, well, another Volvo but possibly — hold me back — a hybrid? I listen to a lot of Tom Petty.

My wish list is kitchen towels.

I am thoroughly washed, and pretty OK with it.

Because of this self-identification and also because the narrator in “Off He Goes” is The One Who Stays, I have always heard the song as centered about their experience, their sadness, their inability to understand The One Who Goes.

My story of the song that has crystallized over the last 25-odd years is The One Who Stays is a child and The One Who Goes is an often-absent father, a take I found utterly compelling and impossibly sad and one that I’m sure I’ll unpack at length in therapy someday.


None of this is to say that I can’t admire The One Who Goes.

A few years back, I was in Chicago for a wedding. Before the wedding, we met up with a friend to do a tour at a brewery.

Most of the other people in our tour happened to be a group of die-hard Pearl Jam fans who followed the band around the country. Pearl Jam was in Chicago, so these folks were too. And everywhere the band went, this group did volunteer work or fundraisers for local charities.

In my exceedingly brief time with them, those disciples who have found another rewarding layer in their fandom, who bounce around the country doing good, all of Them Who Go, seemed to me like possibly the happiest people on this here planet Earth.


We actually don’t have to speculate about what “Off He Goes” is about.

I was listening to it for the zillionth time lately and internet rabbit-holed to an interview in Spin magazine from 2001 where Eddie Vedder said this:

The song “Off He Goes” is really about me being a shit friend. I’ll show up and everything’s great and then all of the sudden I’m outta there…

Ah, so he (Eddie Vedder the person) is The One Who Goes! But because he (Eddie Vedder the lead singer of Pearl Jam) is the narrator, he’s also The One Who Stays — singing about himself, giving voice to those he feels he has wronged.

Empathy, man. Hell of a drug.

Learning this cracked my own hardened perspective a bit.

Then, I felt entirely unmoored — weightless, drifting, powerless — as a wave of understanding hit me and a rip current of sadness pulled me away.

See, I’m just coming back from a whistle-stop tour visiting our families. A few days over one weekend with my wife’s in D.C., a few days the next weekend with mine in Ohio.

I mentioned above that amongst us four siblings, I doubt I’m the favorite.

The lack of grandchildren is one factor, but another mark against me is that I’m the only one that left my hometown. My siblings still live mere minutes from my parents.

When I see my family, I show up and everything’s great then all of the sudden I’m outta there… I’m off again.

Here in lovely North Carolina, I see myself as The One Who Stays.

But to my family, who I see ever briefly, with an entire mountain range between us, I’m The One Who Goes.

…

Ah.


Ok, fine.

Maybe — maybe! — third favorite.

That’s as low as I’m going!


The reason I was listening to “Off He Goes” recently in the first place was Jason Kottke shared an excerpt from the book Thoughts Without a Thinker: Psychotherapy from a Buddhist Perspective by Mark Epstein:

“You see this goblet?” asks Achaan Chaa, the Thai meditation master. “For me this glass is already broken. I enjoy it; I drink out of it. It holds my water admirably, sometimes even reflecting the sun in beautiful patterns. If I should tap it, it has a lovely ring to it. But when I put this glass on the shelf and the wind knocks it over or my elbow brushes it off the table and it falls to the ground and shatters, I say, ‘Of course.’ When I understand that the glass is already broken, every moment with it is precious.”

Because my brain is broken in this particular way where I’m always thinking about either quality potatoes, kitchen towels, or Pearl Jam songs, I immediately started thinking about the dudes in “Off He Goes” from another angle.

I’ve always heard a sad song, but The One Who Stays never says he’s unhappy with his relationship with The One Who Goes. Absolutely there’s an undercurrent of melancholy, but their reunions are joyous.

And now he’s home and we’re laughing
Like we always did
My same old same old friend

Perhaps The One Who Stays, even if they don’t entirely understand, accepts the nature of The One Who Goes.

Perhaps they see that, just like the glass that is already broken, The One Who Goes is already gone. So every moment with them is precious.

Perhaps, knowing this, they enjoy their time together all the more.