
The New York Yankees are coming off another staggering postseason loss after getting swept by the Tampa Bay Rays in the American League Division Series. The Yankees need major changes if they want to return to dominance. Fans had issues at multiple positions around the diamond, highlighted by talk about third baseman Ryan McMahon and second baseman Jazz Chisholm Jr. The Yankees didn’t offer a qualifying offer to Chisholm Jr., presumably cutting ties with the former all-star. Now, McMahon might be the next Yankee on the hot seat. Where do the Yankees go next at third base?
What Was the Expectation?
Before getting traded to the Yankees at the 2025 trade deadline, McMahon spent eight and a half seasons with the Rockies. While he was always a below-average hitter, he had a solid power stroke, hitting 140 home runs in his tenure in Colorado.
He paired that with a .240 batting average and a .743 OPS. Not bad, but his calling card was always his defense. While he’s still without a Gold Glove, he’s consistently been looked at as one of the best defensive third basemen in the MLB. Since 2021, McMahon has accumulated 45 outs above average and an incredible 48 defensive runs saved between 2021 and 2023. Similarly, he had 10 defensive runs saved in 2025, split between the Rockies and Yankees.

So What’s Going Wrong?
Well, he’s coming off the worst season of his career. In 124 games, he batted .211 with 11 home runs, 41 RBI, and a .635 OPS. His .279 on-base percentage would’ve been a bottom-five mark in the MLB if he registered the required number of at-bats. His 76 OPS+ means that he was offensively worse than 24% of all MLB hitters and put up exactly 0.0 WAR. Moreover, he batted .208 with a .641 OPS over his first 54 games with the Yankees in 2025.
While his defense has always been his strong suit, it took a massive dip along with his offense. He put up -2 defensive runs saved and 0 outs above average. He has struggled since joining the Yankees, and it might be time for them to look in a different direction. Let’s take a look at some options:
Already in the System
The Yankees already have a couple of potential options. McMahon goes into 2027 with one year left on his six-year, $70 million contract, so there’s a possibility he’s starting at third base next season. Two other returning players, Anthony Volpe and Jose Caballero, have also spent time at third. Caballero has a lot more experience there, with 120 career games at third compared to one single game for Volpe. Both are also options to play second base if the Yankees do not get a second baseman.
The Yankees will most likely try to fill both positions, but if not, either Volpe or Caballero will fill in whatever position they don’t get. They have some potential prospects in Coby Morales, Roderick Arias, and Core Jackson, but it’s highly unlikely that any of them will be MLB-ready to start the season.

The Market
There has been a lot of talk about Alec Bohm from the Phillies being linked to the Yankees. The Phillies did not extend him a qualifying offer. Bohm batted .249 with 15 home runs, 88 RBI, and a .698 OPS, accumulating a poor -0.2 WAR. While he had a poor season overall and is a below-average defender, Bohm hits lefties very well, batting .292 with seven home runs against lefties last season.
Isaac Paredes is a potential trade candidate who would be a great option for the Yankees. In his age 27 season, Paredes batted .262 with 25 home runs, 94 RBI, and had a .806 OPS en route to a 4.1 WAR. However, the Astros just exercised their $13.35 million club option on him heading into 2027. He’ll probably cost a pretty penny, but would be a phenomenal fit for the Yankees.

Lastly, veteran Eugenio Suarez is on the free agent market. He hit 26 home runs with a .740 OPS last season with the Cincinnati Reds and would be a solid power bat in the Yankees lineup. However, he is in his late 30s and would most likely only be a platoon bat for the Yankees.
What’s The Best Option?
While it would be really nice for the Yankees to get both a second and third baseman, it’ll be hard to land a great player at both positions. So it really just comes down to whichever position the front office needs a star-level player more. Parades would be their best option as of today. If they’re unable to land a third baseman in the market, a platoon between Volpe, McMahon, and Caballero would still provide decent value.
Main Photo Credit: Vincent Carchietta-Imagn Images
More Baseball News:
What Jake Bauers Signing Means For Willson Contreras and the Red Sox



