Ohio State men's basketball coach Jake Diebler would prefer this to the problem he faced a year ago.

When the Buckeyes fought their way into the 2026 NCAA Tournament, they didn't have much of a bench to lean on. Ohio State ranked 327th nationally in percentage of minutes played from its reserves, according to KenPom.com, and that lack of depth ultimately proved critical in Diebler’s second season.

This year’s course correction involved bringing in nine new players, most of whom are reasonably expected to contribute at some meaningful level in 2026-27. But at halftime of a Nov. 16 home game against Prairie View A&M, Diebler got his latest reminder that sometimes you can have too much of a good thing.

Eleven different Buckeyes were on the floor for at least 3:25 of the first half as OSU eked out a 34-29 lead. Diebler shortened his rotation in the second half, and the Buckeyes went on to a comfortable 86-59 win. Afterward, Diebler pointed out how many guys had seen first-half minutes and noted that the coaches were still figuring that out.

He was asked if an 11-man rotation is feasible for an entire season.

“No, I don’t think so,” he answered.

A Nov. 19 home game with UMBC is OSU's last tune-up before another high-major showdown – a Nov. 24 home game against No. 15 Vanderbilt. Ohio State has just four more games against mid-major teams on the schedule, including UMBC.

It’s time for Diebler to start trimming the rotation.

“It’s hard,” he said. “There were many times last year where I would’ve begged to deal with this problem. I still believe this is a good problem to have. We’re evaluating everything, including practice significantly for some guys, to help decide the back end of our rotation.”

The second half against Prairie View A&M was a glimpse into the process. Of the 11 players to see first-half action, three did not step onto the court until the second half was past its midway point and the Ohio State lead was at least 19 points.

Lee Aaliya shoots a three for Ohio State in an 86-59 victory over Prairie View A&M on Monday, Nov. 16, 2026.

In addition to seeing who's performing well on any given game day, Diebler is also using practices to help him divvy up minutes.

Case in point: late-summer acquisition Lee Aaliya. The veteran forward has multiple years of international experience, but his preseason was truncated by an illness just as Diebler said he was starting to hit his stride. The staff still believes that Aaliya will be a significant contributor this season, but he has had just 17:15 of playing time in four appearances to show that.

“Right now we need to put more emphasis on what he’s doing in practice versus the limited opportunity he’s having in the game,” Diebler said. “That’s the most reasonable way to approach it. Now, he needs to practice consistently because he’s getting opportunity to play way more in practice.”

Last season, Ohio State had three games in which at least 10 different players scored at least one point. This year, that has happened in three of the first five games. It’s clear there are more capable players on this year’s roster than at any point in Diebler’s first two full seasons on the job.

For this team to get where it wants to be by season’s end, the playing time is going to start to dwindle for the players at the back end of the rotation. Those are the decisions Diebler and his staff will have to make.

And asked when that needs to start happening, Diebler didn’t hesitate.

“Now,” he said. “I think we have to start being even more specific. We don’t have this runway of games. Every game for us is important. If you drag this out too long, you can almost stunt the growth of the team. That’s the fine line we’re thinking through of how we’re processing that.”

Ohio State men's basketball beat writer Adam Jardy can be reached at ajardy@dispatch.com, on Bluesky at @cdadamjardy.bsky.social, on Instagram at @cdadamjardy or on Twitter at @AdamJardy.

This article originally appeared on The Columbus Dispatch: When does Ohio State need to trim its playing rotation?